Search found 719 matches

by Sagy
Wed May 15, 2024 09:37
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: 2024/25 access list
Replies: 207
Views: 23644

Re: 2024/25 access list

If eg Atalanta wins EL and finish 5th under previous format Italy would have 5-1-1 at competitions. With EPS applying first it would have become 5-2-1 so again Italy has an extra club but not at CL. If Atalanta had finished 4th under previous format they would have 4-2-1 with EPS 5-2-1 so the final...
by Sagy
Tue May 14, 2024 18:04
Forum: European Club football
Topic: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final
Replies: 547
Views: 9628

Re: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final

There are written rules, rule 18, discretion, common practice, game management, and instructions to referees. You are 100% right that other than after a PK was awarded and before it was taken, the CR can end the game whenever they choose. This is the reason the reasons we expect and demand that CR ...
by Sagy
Tue May 14, 2024 09:22
Forum: European Club football
Topic: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final
Replies: 547
Views: 9628

Re: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final

@Polak close to two minutes were wasted in VAR and celebrations so i personally dont have a problem when the match ended. For the record it ended in 90+15. In Valencia the problem with the whistle was that it was during an attack not the time itself. There is no rule saying that the referee can onl...
by Sagy
Sun May 12, 2024 14:33
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: 2024/25 access list
Replies: 207
Views: 23644

Re: 2024/25 access list

bert.kassies , would it be possible to show the points that a team which qualified for European Football but not to a specific competition has? Right now, the qualifications page identify the team (e.g., “Aston Villa qualified for European football”) but doesn’t list the points it has like the team...
by Sagy
Sun May 12, 2024 14:25
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: Battle for important ranking positions 2023-24
Replies: 1103
Views: 103631

Re: Battle for important ranking positions 2023-24

I am not defending their results, quite the opposite. I am just pointing that statistical models are based on, well, statistics about past results + random events (like draws). You are 100% right. Think about it, every day around the world, loto winning numbers are picked. The odds of picking the w...
by Sagy
Sun May 12, 2024 14:16
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: Spreadsheet for European Cups - Feedback & Suggestions
Replies: 302
Views: 39282

Re: Spreadsheet for European Cups - Feedback & Suggestions

However, according regulations which were already quoted, eps is given to the best ranked team which has not qualified "based on domestic championship". So, that means, eps would be given to atalanta no matter that they already qualified by the virtue of europa league winner. But obviousl...
by Sagy
Sun May 12, 2024 08:06
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: Spreadsheet for European Cups - Feedback & Suggestions
Replies: 302
Views: 39282

Re: Spreadsheet for European Cups - Feedback & Suggestions

I really don't get this. Let's assume atalanta wins europa league. Now it is clear that top 5 from serie a qualify for champions league. if atalanta finish 4th in serie a, italy will keep those 5 teams. But if atalanta finish 5th, then italy will earn an extra spot! Keep in mind that last matchday ...
by Sagy
Fri May 10, 2024 09:12
Forum: European Club football
Topic: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final
Replies: 547
Views: 9628

Re: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final

Absolutely. From what I have seen of both clubs this season, the final is reasonably balanced and I expect a competitive game. As a footnote, Real Madrid have never been crowned European champions in England. They also haven't lost a final since the competition officially became the CL. I find it i...
by Sagy
Thu May 09, 2024 23:10
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: 2024/25 access list
Replies: 207
Views: 23644

Re: 2024/25 access list

If my understanding is correct the access list will be rebalanced in every competition based on the access list without taking account the EPS. Then the highest ranked club in of a top2 league that is not at CL-LP will get the EPS, the spot of that club that won EPS will be given to the next highes...
by Sagy
Thu May 09, 2024 15:58
Forum: UEFA club coefficients and rankings
Topic: 2024/25 access list
Replies: 207
Views: 23644

Re: 2024/25 access list

What will happen if Fiorentina wins ECL and finish 8th? Previously they moved two clubs from ECL Q2 to Q3 but since this season no clubs are starting in CoLQ3 could they move 8 clubs from Q1 to Q2? If my understanding is correct the access list will be rebalanced in every competition based on the a...
by Sagy
Thu May 09, 2024 07:15
Forum: European Club football
Topic: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final
Replies: 547
Views: 9628

Re: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final

Before anyone cries about the ref take in mind that: 1 Real got a goal disallowed rightfully so 2 Neuer got Real back into the game 3 its not clear that there was no offside 4 Real stopped playing Lunin didnt even dive for crying out loud Of course there will always be crying when Real wins mainly ...
by Sagy
Wed May 08, 2024 23:49
Forum: European Club football
Topic: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final
Replies: 547
Views: 9628

Re: 2023/24 Champions League quarter-finals, semi-finals and final

Bayern robbed. Nowadays sometimes the play goes on even when there's a ridicolously clear offside, he should not have raised the flag for sure in this case. This was actually a double error. Per the instructions: 1) the AR should have waited with raising the flag. 2) the CR, seeing that the AR rais...
by Sagy
Wed May 08, 2024 10:50
Forum: National Teams
Topic: 2024/25 Concacaf Nations League
Replies: 16
Views: 522

Re: 2024/25 Concacaf Nations League

amenina wrote: Tue May 07, 2024 03:43

Assuming the Gold Cup is 16 teams, that leaves 1 spot most likely for an invited team.
Wild guess…. A random choice between all countries whose name begins with the letter Q 🙄